Well, it’s the beginning of the semester, and I’ve been busy. But let me emerge from the woodwork just long enough to briefly bemoan the loss of a really excellent product–the late great Rio Karma. The Karma’s successor products, poised for release, will now never make it to market.
Now, while no reader of tdq is especially likely to care, the company that produced what is by far the best digital audio player available has today gone out of business. It’s frustrating, becuase hardly anyone even knew what a Rio Karma was. And it’s frustrating not only because as in the contest bewteen vhs and beta the techincally inferior product was bested by marketing muscle and savvy, but becuase the ascendency of the iPod is the ascendency of Apple’s closed source and oppressive DRM model of software/hardware/music, that tries to lock customers into the apple brand by pushing them to buy music in formats that play only on apple’s music players.
The Rio Karma was notably superior to the iPod in just about every respect:
+it plays ogg vorbis (open source; better sound quality/smaller file size), as well as FLAC (lossless open source compression)
+Better sound quality, plus a five band parametric equalizer with adjustable bandwidths.
+And most of all, that it has true gapless playback.
This last item, gapless, has become sort of important to me, and it would now be annoying to me to listen to (for example) classical music with little gaps in between each mp3 track. It just seems weird that other players can’t manage to play an album back without inserting gaps between each track even when the tracks are supposed to be connected.
Ok, finally, what really gets me is the constant insistance by iPod fans on the brilliance of the iPod design. From a purely aesthetic standpoint, the iPod does have a clean futuristic look. But I’ve nver been overwhelmed by the wonders of the clickwheel. To me, it seems awkward. I mean, just watch people using their iPods–everyone uses two hands, because it’s really hard to use the thing one-handed. It’s designed to look pretty, and not to be really functional. The Karma can (unless you are really tiny-handed) be easily operated with just one hand.
Anyway, I just might try and buy a spare Karma, as I wait for the rest of the digital players to achieve the feature set the Karma managed a couple years ago. (The Cowon x5/m5 players look promising but still fall short.) If you too are thinking about a Karma, you’d better hurry, since now that Rio is closing, the supply of remaining Karmas (you can find them cheap now–maybe $160 on Ebay), will soon be depleted, and you will find yourself lost in a world without Karma.